Carol D. Calamari
    ERA Distinctive Properties℠

    Carol D. Calamari

    Satisfaction Rating An agent's star rating is the average of all the ratings of their service.
    Carol D. Calamari epitomizes hard work, energy, integrity and creative service in every detail of your real estate transaction. Carol has been selling and listing properties in Bergen, Essex, Hudson, Monmouth, Ocean, Passaic, and Union, Counties for over the last 20 years.

    Clients choose to work with Carol for her full-service firm, ethics, experience, and expertise. Carol has consistently shown the ability to satisfy clients in the buying and selling of their homes. Her strong base of loyal repeat customers is the reason for Carol's success. Quite simply, she is trusted.

    Carol's knowledge of Rutherford, the surrounding Meadowlands area and as far south as the Jersey Shore, in residential real estate market, is unparalleled.

    Carol prides herself on giving all of her clients the most precise and up-to-date feedback on the state of the market, its trends, comparable sales, and property values, giving them a realistic outlook on what they can expect to achieve in today's market.

    Carol has been nominated by clients and has received the 5-Star Professional Real Estate award as featured in New Jersey Monthly Magazine for delivering overall satisfaction and exemplary customer service. She also serves as a Mentor for new agents.

    My Client Reviews

    Overall star rating: 5.0
    Past 3 months: N/A

    Ratings Breakdown

    Star Rating Percentage of reviews with this rating Number of reviews with this rating
    5 stars
    100% of Carol D.’s ratings: 5 stars
    4 stars
    0% of Carol D.’s ratings: 4 stars
    3 stars
    0% of Carol D.’s ratings: 3 stars
    2 stars
    0% of Carol D.’s ratings: 2 stars
    1 stars
    0% of Carol D.’s ratings: 1 star

    Showing All Reviews (11)

    Show only: 5 stars 4 stars 3 stars 2 stars 1 star show all
    Tan gave Carol D. 5 stars out of 5
    Carol was a pleasure to work with. She not only helped us buy our house but also aided in selling it years later. Carol is not only professional, but very personable. I would definitely recommend her to people looking to buy in Rutherford & the surrounding neighborhoods!
    Ian and Emma gave Carol D. 5 stars out of 5
    Carol was the best! She was very easy to work with and knew more about the Rutherford area than anyone else. My favorite part about Carol is from Day 1 it felt like she wanted to make sure we found the right house for us. It never felt like she was pushing particular houses on us. She just wanted to make sure we ended up in a place where we were happy. And we did in large part thanks to her. I would tell anyone looking in the area that Carol is your best bet!
    Melinda gave Carol D. 5 stars out of 5
    Carol was the perfect realtor for me. She recognized the emotional difficulties in selling the house where I grew up and did not pressure me to list until I (and the house) was ready. She provided staging advice, recommendations for electricians and other handymen, knowledge of town requirements, empathy, compassion, and constant communication. She even assisted in trying to sell some of the house contents. I am glad I listened to all her advice. The house sold at 95% of the listing price even before it hit the MLS !! Thank you Carol. : - )
    Bobby gave Carol D. 5 stars out of 5
    Carol is an extremely knowledgeable realtor of the properties that she handles. She helped my family and I sell my fathers property which was a seemless transaction. She had a steady flow of potential buyers come in and we were able to sell and close the deal in a more than reasonable time frame. She is very personable, professional, and treats her clients as if she were part of her family. She is a huge asset to the ERA Realtor company. I would highly recommend her for anyone's future property sale. Sincerely, Robert Cahill and the Cahill Family.
    Response from Carol D.
    Hi Bobby, It was a pleasure working for you and your family in the successful sale of your fathers property. I strive to keep my clients in the loop throughout the process and happy at the same time. It's a team effort! Thanks again for trusting in me! Carol
    Patti gave Carol D. 5 stars out of 5
    Carol is a true professional. We have worked with her when we had apartments to rent and recently to sell a home. She is extremely knowledgeable very responsive and a true pleasure to work with. We have recommended her to friends and family and look forward to working with her again.
    Response from Carol D.
    Hi Patti, I am pleased you and Chris were happy with my services in selling your investment property. I work hard to make the process of selling properties as painless as possible (even for the tenants). It's important for me to provide feedback from showings, respond as quickly as possible to questions you may have had and get the best price in the current market. I'd be happy to assist you, friends and family with any real estate needs. Thanks again! Carol
    Susan gave Carol D. 5 stars out of 5
    Carol was confident from day one that I would sell my house at a fair price to the right buyer. She was right. In addition she is a very ethical and honest professional. I would and have recommended her to others.
    Response from Carol D.
    Hi Sue, Thanks so much for your kind words. It was a pleasure working for you and getting your house sold to the right buyer!
    Peter gave Carol D. 5 stars out of 5
    I had the pleasure to work with Carol this past year! I had recently inherited my Mothers' home in Rutherford NJ and was investigating all my options ,including the sale of the home.Carol was extremely helpful in promptly providing me with all the information / facts etc. needed to make an intelligent decision regarding the home.She is a true professional ,knowledgeable and a genuine person.
    Bobby gave Carol D. 5 stars out of 5
    I have used Carol on several deals and she's been amazing on each and every deal! I have referred friends and co-workers to Carol and they all had the same great results as I! She' a TRUE Professional!
    Schmitt gave Carol D. 5 stars out of 5
    Not only is Carol extremely knowledgeable in her field, she is passionate about homes and can really help you see the potential in the most unexpected properties. Carol is friendly, helpful and very dedicated to finding the best place to suit your needs. She grew up in Rutherford so Carol knows the beauty and charm that the homes and apartment buildings in this town have. Finding an apartment can be difficult but Carol helped me find the right place at the right price. Carol is definitely the one to call at Justin Realty!
    Timothy gave Carol D. 5 stars out of 5
    Meeting Carol Calamari many years ago was the best thing that could have happened for our family. She is HONEST, patient and best of all a delight to be around. Carol always has her clients best interests in mind. Her expierence is far superior to the vast majority of the industry agents which is comforting to say the least. There is no one better!!
    Rob gave Carol D. 5 stars out of 5
    Carol has always displayed a sense of what a buyer or renter is truly looking for. She prices to sell without compromising her clients best interest. She is trustworthy and dedicated to both her clients and her profession.

    My Experience

    • Carol has achieved the distinguished NJAR Circle of Excellence Bronze Award 2002, '03, '06, '09, '10, '12 & '16, Silver Award '14 - '15 , '17-'21. Carol has been named Bergen County Top Real Estate Agent in BERGEN Magazine April 2018 issue.
    • Carol comes from a 18 year television career covering 4 Winter and 1 Summer Olympic Games working most recently on the 2002 Salt Lake City Games. In addition to working with CBS and NBC, Carol has also worked on shows such as "Who Wants to be a Millionaire", Martha Stewart and with MTV/VH1.
    • Working worldwide and with various television personalities has given Calamari a vast knowledge of abilities for working with people and a sense of service, attributes naturally related to the real estate industry.
    • Calamari, a lifelong resident of Rutherford, was also awarded the 1998 National Sports Emmy Award for Outstanding Program Achievement.
    • Carol's business background truly will compliment her abilities in service and dealing with buyers and sellers throughout our communities.

    My Credentials and Memberships

    • Fairleigh Dickinson University, Bachelor of Science in Finance and Economics
    • Kovats School of Real Estate
    • National Association of REALTORS, New Jersey Association of REALTORS
    • Greater Bergen REALTORS, NEXUS Association of REALTORS
    • NJMLS, GSMLS, Hudson County MLS, Bright MLS, Monmouth MLS
    • New Jersey REALTORS 2021 Circle of Excellence Committee
    • Greater Bergen REALTORS Circle of Excellence Committee 2003-2020, '22
    • Rutherford Historic Preservation Committee since 2018-2020
    • Greater Bergen REALTORS International Committee 2008-2009, Task Force 2008 & 2010, Green Committee 2010

    My Community Involvement

    • CERT - Community Emergency Response Team
    • Relay For Life - American Cancer Society
    • MDA - Muscular Dystrophy Association
    • Star Fish Project - ERA Justin Realty Co

    Local Insights

    Calamari Properties Blog

    Carol D. Calamari Reviews National Historic Homes

    Carol D. Calamari, a Realtor with ERA Justin Realty, partnering with the National Trust for Historic Preservation has been certified for her educational outreach, centering on the preservation and restoration of historic properties.  Having achieved this designation makes her familiar with architecture that spans more than three centuries of history, highlighting both high-style and vernacular buildings ranging from stately Federal mansions and handsome Italianate row ho...
    Oct 17, 2017 New & Newsworthy

    My Video

    Follow Me

    Share My Page

    Go Mobile

    Want to take your search on the go and find nearby homes? Download my free mobile app.

    Goto Apple app store to download iOS app Goto Google play store to download the app


    Any services or products provided by third parties are not provided by, affiliated with, or related to ERA Franchise Systems LLC or its affiliated companies.