51 Sherrill Street, Geneva, NY 14456
Local realty services provided by:ERA Team VP Real Estate



51 Sherrill Street,Geneva, NY 14456
$325,000
- 5 Beds
- 4 Baths
- 3,100 sq. ft.
- Multi-family
- Active
Listed by:esthervina mallard
Office:coldwell banker finger lakes
MLS#:R1611370
Source:NY_GENRIS
Price summary
- Price:$325,000
- Price per sq. ft.:$104.84
About this home
A grand opportunity awaits at 51 Sherrill Street in the heart of Geneva’s Lehigh Gardens neighborhood, a community known for its historic charm . This home, once a single-family residence, has been thoughtfully converted into a spacious two-unit property that is perfect for investors, house-hackers, or multigenerational living.
The first-floor unit features a generous layout with large, light-filled rooms, an eat-in kitchen, a formal dining room with hardwood floors, and a cozy living room that includes a mirrored mantel and a non-working fireplace. This unit also offers 2 bedrooms, an enclosed back porch, and in-unit laundry for added convenience.
The second-floor unit has been beautifully updated and includes three bedrooms and two-and-a-half bathrooms. It offers hardwood floors, a modern kitchen, and a spacious, flexible layout that can easily accommodate a home office or den. There is also second-floor laundry and private access to both the front foyer and the home’s classic wraparound porch. A standout feature of this unit is its exclusive access to a private, covered upper-level porch that overlooks the quiet street and is a perfect spot to enjoy morning coffee or evening relaxation.
Recent updates to the property include new siding, a new tankless water heater, a new furnace for the first floor. Several windows have been replaced, and the shared driveway with plenty of parking.The backyard includes a storage shed, a firepit, and a seating area ideal for quiet evenings outside.
With over 3100 square feet of space, separate utilities, and thoughtful improvements throughout, this property blends classic beauty with modern functionality. Whether you’re looking for an income-producing investment or a flexible living arrangement, this gem offers rare potential in a prime Geneva location. Situated just minutes from downtown, the lakefront, and Hobart & William Smith Colleges, this home is also within walking distance to Geneva General Hospital, making it an ideal option for healthcare workers or anyone seeking convenience without compromising charm. Schedule your showing today!
Contact an agent
Home facts
- Year built:1885
- Listing Id #:R1611370
- Added:74 day(s) ago
- Updated:August 18, 2025 at 03:38 PM
Rooms and interior
- Bedrooms:5
- Total bathrooms:4
- Full bathrooms:3
- Half bathrooms:1
- Living area:3,100 sq. ft.
Heating and cooling
- Heating:Baseboard, Forced Air, Gas
Structure and exterior
- Roof:Asphalt
- Year built:1885
- Building area:3,100 sq. ft.
- Lot area:0.15 Acres
Utilities
- Water:Connected, Public, Water Connected
- Sewer:Connected, Sewer Connected
Finances and disclosures
- Price:$325,000
- Price per sq. ft.:$104.84
- Tax amount:$4,326
New listings near 51 Sherrill Street
- New$199,900Active3 beds 2 baths1,127 sq. ft.
128 Garden Street, Geneva, NY 14456
MLS# R1630702Listed by: THE YOUNG AGENCY - New$249,900Active5 beds 3 baths2,218 sq. ft.
207-209 Pulteney Street, Geneva, NY 14456
MLS# R1629018Listed by: LAKE TO LAKE REAL ESTATE - New$649,900Active3 beds 1 baths1,184 sq. ft.
4847 Crazy Cove, Geneva, NY 14456
MLS# R1629586Listed by: GEOCA HOMES LLC - New$389,000Active5 beds 3 baths2,632 sq. ft.
179 Dwyer Drive, Geneva, NY 14456
MLS# R1629495Listed by: COLDWELL BANKER FINGER LAKES - New$249,900Active3 beds 2 baths1,408 sq. ft.
24 Oak Street, Geneva, NY 14456
MLS# R1628821Listed by: HOWARD HANNA - $250,000Pending3 beds 2 baths1,506 sq. ft.
302 Washington Street, Geneva, NY 14456
MLS# R1627933Listed by: COLDWELL BANKER FINGER LAKES - $165,000Active3 beds 2 baths1,328 sq. ft.
10 Worthington Avenue, Geneva, NY 14456
MLS# R1626223Listed by: TICKLE REALTY, LLC - $399,900Active5 beds -- baths5,280 sq. ft.
110-112 Andes Avenue #110, Geneva, NY 14456
MLS# R1626369Listed by: TICKLE REALTY, LLC - $989,000Active3 beds 2 baths2,059 sq. ft.
4108-4109 High Banks, Geneva, NY 14456
MLS# R1624191Listed by: HOWARD HANNA - $319,900Active4 beds 2 baths3,012 sq. ft.
211 S West Street, Geneva, NY 14456
MLS# R1626421Listed by: CENTURY 21 STEVE DAVOLI RE