2560 May Road, Hagaman, NY 12086
Local realty services provided by:HUNT Real Estate ERA
2560 May Road,Galway, NY 12086
$824,900
- 2 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 1,284 sq. ft.
- Single family
- Active
Listed by:heather etzel
Office:four seasons sotheby's international realty
MLS#:202522647
Source:Global MLS
Price summary
- Price:$824,900
- Price per sq. ft.:$642.45
- Monthly HOA dues:$18.75
About this home
Welcome to Pine Hollow, a private, year-round sanctuary nestled along the tranquil shores of Galway Lake. Set on a rare and expansive .44-acre lot with 144 feet of pristine lake frontage, this custom-crafted home is one of the few true four-season residences on the lake, offering peaceful views and direct water access in every season.
From the moment you arrive, Pine Hollow feels like a retreat from the world—where time slows down and moments become memories. Mornings begin with a quiet paddle, and evenings end around the crackling fire pit, wrapped in blankets and stories. Whether you’re watching snowflakes swirl outside the window or listening to summer rain dance on the roof, this is a place that holds you close through every season.
Thoughtfully renovated in 2005 and lovingly enhanced ever since, the home blends rustic charm with whimsical character. Inside, knotty pine walls, wide-plank floors, stained glass transoms, and a custom hobbit-style front door create a warm, inviting space that feels both grounded and magical. Nearly every room, including the vaulted post-and-beam living room, both bedrooms, and the sunroom, offers views of the lake that change with the light and the seasons.
The kitchen charms with its Dutch door, handcrafted tile, and custom wood countertops made from locally sourced lumber. On the walkout lower level, you’ll find a full eat-in second kitchen with matching custom wood countertops, a new half bath, and a cozy wood-burning fireplace anchoring the family room—perfect for guests, multigenerational living, or hosting lakeside gatherings.
But it’s the outdoors that truly captures the heart. Three separate stone patios, including one with a steel and stone fire pit, invite long conversations and stargazing. Three terraced decks offer layered views of the lake and woods, each level providing a new perspective and purpose. A new lower deck, completed in 2024, leads seamlessly to the water’s edge, where a private boat dock and swimming platform await. This area of the lake offers a deep-water entrance—perfect for diving right in, launching a kayak, or joyfully jumping off the dock. Whether you’re savoring a sunrise swim or docking after a sunset paddle, every inch of this lakeside landscape is designed for connection, laughter, and lasting memories.
Additional outdoor features include a boat shed, custom boat racks, a 12-person cedar picnic table, lush perennial gardens, and a potting shed with sliding barn doors. There’s even room to expand—or simply take in the rare sense of space that this lot offers, something few lakefront homes can claim.
Additional interior features include Andersen windows, custom closets throughout, a cedar closet, EV charger, ADT security system, and a water treatment system.
Located on a non-motorized (electric motors allowed), private lake, Galway Lake offers calm waters perfect for swimming, boating, paddling, and unplugged living. Whether you’re seeking a full-time home or a four-season escape, Pine Hollow is more than a property—it’s a place to slow down, reconnect, and begin the next chapter of your story.
Contact an agent
Home facts
- Year built:1940
- Listing ID #:202522647
- Added:95 day(s) ago
- Updated:November 01, 2025 at 04:35 PM
Rooms and interior
- Bedrooms:2
- Total bathrooms:3
- Full bathrooms:2
- Half bathrooms:1
- Living area:1,284 sq. ft.
Heating and cooling
- Cooling:Window Unit(s)
- Heating:Baseboard, Hot Water, Propane
Structure and exterior
- Roof:Asphalt, Shingle
- Year built:1940
- Building area:1,284 sq. ft.
- Lot area:0.44 Acres
Schools
- High school:Galway
- Elementary school:Joseph Henry
Utilities
- Sewer:Septic Tank
Finances and disclosures
- Price:$824,900
- Price per sq. ft.:$642.45
- Tax amount:$4,366
New listings near 2560 May Road
$80,000Active3 beds 2 baths1,342 sq. ft.7 Main Street, Hagaman, NY 12086
MLS# 202527682Listed by: HOWARD HANNA CAPITAL INC
$314,900Active3 beds 2 baths1,805 sq. ft.245 Scenic Drive, Hagaman, NY 12086
MLS# 202526417Listed by: EMPIRE REAL ESTATE FIRM LLC
$345,000Active4 beds 2 baths1,800 sq. ft.14 Lansing Street, Hagaman, NY 12086
MLS# 202522322Listed by: CHAD MAJEWSKI REAL ESTATE
$165,900Active4 beds 1 baths1,440 sq. ft.34 Haskell Street, Hagaman, NY 12086
MLS# 202518272Listed by: COLDWELL BANKER PRIME PROPERTIES
$199,900Pending3 beds 2 baths1,270 sq. ft.13 N Pawling Street, Hagaman, NY 12086
MLS# 202416009Listed by: CENTURY 21 - PURTELL REALTY
Protect your home and budget with an American Home Shield© home warranty. Learn more© 2023 - 2025 ERA Franchise Systems LLC. All rights reserved. ERA Franchise Systems LLC fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act. ERA, ERA Real Estate powered, and their respective logos are registered service marks of ERA Franchise Systems LLC. Each office is independently owned and operated.