440 Park Avenue, Waverly, NY 14892
Local realty services provided by:HUNT Real Estate ERA
440 Park Avenue,Waverly, NY 14892
$495,000
- 6 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 3,569 sq. ft.
- Single family
- Active
Listed by:erin harder
Office:realty one group supreme
MLS#:R1607461
Source:NY_GENRIS
Price summary
- Price:$495,000
- Price per sq. ft.:$138.69
About this home
A Historic Gem: that is NOT IN A FLOOD ZONE and furniture is negotiable! Step back in time while enjoying traditional comfort in this exquisite 1874 Second Empire Victorian, once home to the esteemed Dr. William Elting Johnson—renowned New York State Senator and beloved physician of the area. This stately 6-bedroom, 2.5-bath residence is not only a piece of Waverly’s history, but a living legacy. Constructed between 1869 & 1880 with thoughtful additions in 1880 and a kitchen modernization in the 1920s (now updated), the home is rumored to have hosted President William McKinley during a visit—adding presidential prestige to its story. Original blueprints, historical letters, and documents are included with the sale, preserving the home's rich narrative. In 1930, the home was acquired by Dr. Schamel, who established a thriving labor and delivery practice. It’s said that nearly everyone in the village was born here—further deepening its connection to the community.
This residence seamlessly blends historical integrity with over $100,000 in thoughtful upgrades:
All-new electrical wiring and updated panels.
New underground natural gas service and high-efficiency furnace (2024, $12K investment)
50-gallon electric water heater (2023) with full-house water treatment system
Brand new acrylic roofing with venting, painted white for energy efficiency, plus red-accented porch roofs, including all window dormers, complemented by 6” seamless copper gutters, spouts, and Yankee gutters
Four original chimneys restored to period-correct condition
Fresh, top-tier exterior paint throughout (house and carriage house)
Carriage house features new roof, electric garage and barn doors
The charm continues inside with Tiffany-style ceiling fans in every room, restored heating systems, and original architectural features including the house’s original hitching post, stepping stone, and slate floors in the basement and walkways.
This is not just a home—it’s a story, a landmark, and a rare opportunity to own a piece of New York history. Whether you're an old-home lover, a history buff, or someone looking for a truly one-of-a-kind residence, 1874 Waverly awaits your next chapter.
Contact an agent
Home facts
- Year built:1874
- Listing Id #:R1607461
- Added:92 day(s) ago
- Updated:August 16, 2025 at 02:54 PM
Rooms and interior
- Bedrooms:6
- Total bathrooms:3
- Full bathrooms:2
- Half bathrooms:1
- Living area:3,569 sq. ft.
Heating and cooling
- Heating:Gas, Hot Water
Structure and exterior
- Roof:Flat, Shingle
- Year built:1874
- Building area:3,569 sq. ft.
- Lot area:0.42 Acres
Utilities
- Water:Connected, Public, Water Connected
- Sewer:Connected, Sewer Connected
Finances and disclosures
- Price:$495,000
- Price per sq. ft.:$138.69
- Tax amount:$6,218
New listings near 440 Park Avenue
- New
$140,000Active-- beds -- baths553 Clark St, Waverly, NY 14892
MLS# 31723023Listed by: REALTY ONE GROUP SUPREME - New
$279,000Active3 beds 2 baths1,912 sq. ft.177 Ridge Rd., Waverly, NY 14892
MLS# 31723015Listed by: COLDWELL BANKER PREFERRED PROPERTIES - SAYRE - New
$185,000Active3 beds 1 baths1,224 sq. ft.237 Erie St, Waverly, NY 14892
MLS# 31722961Listed by: HOWARD HANNA AT HOME REALTY 
$60,000Pending3 beds 2 baths2,682 sq. ft.18 Austin Dr, Waverly, NY 14892
MLS# 31722958Listed by: REALTY ONE GROUP SUPREME
$249,900Active3 beds 3 baths2,372 sq. ft.471 Pennsylvania Avenue, Waverly, NY 14892
MLS# R1626360Listed by: WARREN REAL ESTATE
$137,000Active2 beds 1 baths1,272 sq. ft.519 E Chemung Street, Waverly, NY 14892
MLS# 31722903Listed by: KNOLLES REAL ESTATE, LLC
$98,500Active2 beds 1 baths910 sq. ft.219 Talamadge Hill West, Waverly, NY 14892
MLS# 31722896Listed by: CENTURY 21 JACKSON REAL ESTATE - ATHENS
$135,000Active3 beds 2 baths1,852 sq. ft.451 Waverly Street, Waverly, NY 14892
MLS# 31722882Listed by: COLDWELL BANKER PREFERRED PROPERTIES - SAYRE
$179,900Active3 beds 2 baths1,568 sq. ft.112 County Route 60, Waverly, NY 14892
MLS# R1623378Listed by: SIGNATURE PROPERTIES
$164,500Active4 beds 2 baths1,622 sq. ft.424 Loder Street, Waverly, NY 14892
MLS# R1622881Listed by: WARREN REAL ESTATE
Protect your home and budget with an American Home Shield© home warranty. Learn more© 2023 - 2025 ERA Franchise Systems LLC. All rights reserved. ERA Franchise Systems LLC fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act. ERA, ERA Real Estate powered, and their respective logos are registered service marks of ERA Franchise Systems LLC. Each office is independently owned and operated.