3969 Route 394, Mayville, NY 14757
Local realty services provided by:HUNT Real Estate ERA
3969 Route 394,Mayville, NY 14757
$399,750
- 4 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 2,224 sq. ft.
- Single family
- Active
Listed by: karen goodell
Office: era team vp real estate
MLS#:R1653014
Source:NY_GENRIS
Price summary
- Price:$399,750
- Price per sq. ft.:$179.74
About this home
Step into a home unlike any other! This former church has been thoughtfully transformed into a warm and inviting 4 bedroom 2.5 bath home featuring a cozy loft perfect for a hangout space or year round retreat.
The moment you walk in, you’ll be welcomed by soaring ceilings, beautiful natural light, and preserved architectural details—including several decorative, church-style windows that add a beautiful touch of character and history. The expansive great room serves as the heart of the home, combining the living, dining, and kitchen areas into one open, airy space ideal for gatherings.
All 4 bedrooms offer comfortable space and flexibility, making this home suitable for a variety of needs—whether full-time living or vacationing.
Upstairs, the loft adds even more versatility—a perfect spot for a reading nook, gaming space or office. Please note, about 300 sq. feet in this area is in addition to the approximate 2300 sq. feet listed.
Originally built in 1858 and decommissioned after 165 years, this former church has been carefully rebuilt and updated. Significant improvements include reinforced floor joists, new flooring, new heating and electrical systems, a new well, and a new septic holding tank (public sewer available in 2026). Additional updates include all-new siding, insulation, and 10 new windows. The home features a custom kitchen with stainless steel appliances, a large island, and solid surface countertops. The 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, and ample closet space throughout were thoughtfully created from the former classrooms. Located at the attractive rear entrance, the home features a new laundry area and mechanical closet, with plenty of space for storage. The rear area of the property offers plenty of room for parking, the potential for a garage, and a relaxing rear terrace.
Located just two miles from Chautauqua Institution, close to Chautauqua Lake, and near popular snowmobile trail systems, this property offers the perfect blend of historic charm, modern comfort, and access to year-round recreation—from arts and culture to boating, fishing, and winter sports
If you're looking for character, space, and a home that truly stands out—this is it.
Contact an agent
Home facts
- Year built:1858
- Listing ID #:R1653014
- Added:5 day(s) ago
- Updated:December 18, 2025 at 04:02 PM
Rooms and interior
- Bedrooms:4
- Total bathrooms:3
- Full bathrooms:2
- Half bathrooms:1
- Living area:2,224 sq. ft.
Heating and cooling
- Heating:Forced Air, Gas
Structure and exterior
- Roof:Metal
- Year built:1858
- Building area:2,224 sq. ft.
- Lot area:0.36 Acres
Utilities
- Water:Well
Finances and disclosures
- Price:$399,750
- Price per sq. ft.:$179.74
- Tax amount:$2,075
New listings near 3969 Route 394
$250,000Pending81.62 Acres0 Mather Road, Mayville, NY 14757
MLS# R1652166Listed by: HOWARD HANNA HOLT - MAYVILLE- New
$549,999Active61.34 Acres4437 Hewes Road, Mayville, NY 14757
MLS# R1653950Listed by: MOSSY OAK PROPERTIES 
$500,000Active7 beds 3 baths3,176 sq. ft.6040 & 6044 Mill Road, Mayville, NY 14757
MLS# R1652547Listed by: HOWARD HANNA HOLT - MAYVILLE
$500,000Active7 beds 3 baths3,176 sq. ft.6040 & 6044 Mill Road, Mayville, NY 14757
MLS# R1652548Listed by: HOWARD HANNA HOLT - MAYVILLE
Listed by ERA$44,900Active0.61 Acres2013 (Lot 7) Mandolin Ridge, Mayville, NY 14757
MLS# R1651664Listed by: ERA TEAM VP REAL ESTATE
Listed by ERA$44,900Active0.53 Acres2045 (Lot 15) Mandolin Ridge, Mayville, NY 14757
MLS# R1651670Listed by: ERA TEAM VP REAL ESTATE
Listed by ERA$44,900Active0.42 Acres2097 (Lot 28) Mandolin Ridge, Mayville, NY 14757
MLS# R1652039Listed by: ERA TEAM VP REAL ESTATE
Listed by ERA$44,900Active0.4 Acres3001 (Lot 29) Mandolin Ridge, Mayville, NY 14757
MLS# R1652040Listed by: ERA TEAM VP REAL ESTATE
Listed by ERA$44,900Active0.52 Acres3005 (Lot 30) Mandolin Ridge, Mayville, NY 14757
MLS# R1652041Listed by: ERA TEAM VP REAL ESTATE
Protect your home and budget with an American Home Shield© home warranty. Learn more© 2023 - 2025 ERA Franchise Systems LLC. All rights reserved. ERA Franchise Systems LLC fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act. ERA, ERA Real Estate powered, and their respective logos are registered service marks of ERA Franchise Systems LLC. Each office is independently owned and operated.